🎬 Watch the Full Video
The Texas Immigration Landscape: Understanding Your Rights in a Time of Crisis
As legal professionals who have served the Houston community and greater Texas for over two decades, we at Attorney911 witness firsthand how shifting federal policies create waves of fear and uncertainty that ripple through our neighborhoods. The conversation in our recent podcast episode, “Immigration in Houston: Birthright, ICE Raids, Work Permits & Trump Policy Changes,” highlighted critical issues facing families across our state. While The Manginello Law Firm, PLLC, focuses primarily on personal injury and criminal defense litigation, our deep roots in Texas law and our daily work within the justice system give us a unique perspective on how enforcement actions affect the community we serve. When any governmental power operates without clear direction or respect for fundamental rights, it creates a legal environment where everyone—regardless of status—deserves to understand their position and protections. This article expands on that crucial discussion, providing context, clarity, and actionable guidance from a Texas legal standpoint.
The Fundamental Principle of Birthright Citizenship: More Than Political Debate
The notion of challenging birthright citizenship strikes at the very heart of the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which states, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” This isn’t a policy preference; it’s a constitutional guarantee ratified in 1868. As discussed in our podcast, the idea of ending this right feels “un-American” to many who grew up with this foundational principle. From a purely legal analytical standpoint, the argument that significant numbers of people undertake the dangerous and costly journey to the United States primarily to give birth for citizenship benefits lacks substantial empirical data. As the conversation noted, Customs and Border Protection has for years been vigilant in turning away women who appear to be entering the country while pregnant, if they suspect the intent is to give birth. The reality observed by attorneys on the ground in Houston and across Texas is that this phenomenon is not the driving force behind migration patterns that are far more complex, involving flight from violence, economic desperation, and family reunification.
Why does this matter to everyone in Texas? Constitutional stability matters. When core, settled principles of law are floated for revision for political purposes, it creates instability that affects legal predictability for everyone. At Attorney911, Managing Partner Ralph Manginello’s 25+ years of litigation experience have taught him that the strength of our system relies on consistent application of foundational rules. Whether we’re fighting a multi-million dollar injury case against a billion-dollar corporation or examining a government action, the principles of due process and equal protection under law must be steadfast.
The Reality of ICE Raids and Enforcement: From “Criminals” to a Wide Net
A particularly alarming shift discussed in depth is the evolution of immigration enforcement priorities. Initially framed as a focused effort to remove “violent criminals,” the policy appears to have rapidly expanded into widespread operations targeting non-criminal individuals at their workplaces. As noted in our podcast, this has severe economic repercussions across Texas, affecting the hospitality industry, restaurants, hotels, construction, landscaping, and agriculture—sectors integral to our state’s economy. The rhetorical question posed was poignant: “How many violent criminals are applying to wash clothes and clean rooms at hotels for seventeen dollars an hour?”
The tactical shift suggests a move toward what was termed “low-hanging fruit”—easily identifiable workplaces with concentrations of Hispanic workers—to meet apparent arrest quotas. This approach raises serious legal and ethical concerns. From a criminal defense perspective, which is a core practice area for our firm, effective and legitimate law enforcement should be intelligence-driven, targeting specific individuals based on evidence of criminal activity, not conducting generalized sweeps based on ethnicity or workplace. Such sweeps can easily ensnare individuals with pending applications, those with legitimate claims to relief, or even U.S. citizens or legal permanent residents, as seen in notable cases where ICE detained members of Congress and other officials.
The Insider View on Quotas and Pressure
The podcast revealed a critical insight: a lack of organization and top-down pressure in the form of escalating quotas. When agencies are directed to produce numerical results—”3,000 people a day”—without clear, lawful guidance on who should be targeted, it inevitably leads to a focus on volume over justice. This creates a moral conflict for individual officers and undermines the professionalism of the agencies involved. In our complex litigation, such as our involvement in the BP Texas City explosion cases, we’ve seen how pressure from large organizations can lead to catastrophic outcomes when proper procedures are bypassed. The same dynamic appears at play here: a top-down mandate for numbers, leading to operations that are, as described, “not thought out” and lacking a coherent plan, ultimately harming communities, families, and the integrity of the system itself.
The Universal Question: “How Do I Get a Work Permit?”
Across 35 years of observation, one question remains universal from individuals navigating the system: “How do I get a work permit?” This is not a question about seeking “free stuff” or benefits, as our podcast guest emphasized. It is a fundamental question about dignity, self-sufficiency, and the ability to provide for one’s family. The work permit (Employment Authorization Document or EAD) is often the first tangible step toward stability and compliance for many immigrants. The legal pathways to obtaining one are narrow and specific, typically tied to a pending application for a status that allows work, such as asylum, a family-based visa petition, or a U-visa for victims of crime.
The intense focus on this document highlights a core disconnect in policy. There is a demonstrated labor demand in Texas for workers in various sectors, and there are individuals eager to work legally and contribute. Yet, the legal channels to match this supply with demand are incredibly limited, pushing many into undocumented work out of necessity. This creates a precarious situation for workers, leaving them vulnerable to exploitation by unscrupulous employers and now, to targeted enforcement actions. From a legal standpoint, creating more accessible, controlled avenues for work authorization would address economic needs while bringing people out of the shadows, a point of consensus among many business leaders in Texas.
The Legal Labyrinth: 10-Year Bars, Waivers, and Being “Trapped”
One of the most complex areas explained in our discussion is the concept of the “10-year bar” and the related waivers. This is a perfect example of how well-intentioned laws can create unintended human consequences. Under Section 212(a)(9)(B) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, an individual who accrues more than 180 days but less than one year of unlawful presence in the U.S. and then departs is barred from returning for three years. If the unlawful presence is one year or more, the bar is ten years.
For many long-term Texas residents with U.S. citizen spouses or children, this law creates an impossible choice. They may be eligible for a green card through their family, but because they entered without inspection or overstayed a visa, they must return to their home country for an interview at the U.S. consulate. The moment they leave, the 10-year bar is triggered, separating them from their family for a decade. The only escape is a waiver, called the I-601A Provisional Unlawful Presence Waiver, which requires proving that their U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse or parent would suffer “extreme hardship” if the family were separated.
The Gray Area of “Registration” and Pending Waivers
A critical point of anxiety identified involves individuals who are in the process of doing everything right. They have a U.S. citizen petitioner, have filed for a waiver, and are waiting. Historically, these individuals were allowed to remain in the U.S. while their waiver was processed. Now, with talk of enforcing a long-dormant “registration” requirement, these individuals in legal limbo fear they may not be considered “registered” and thus are at high risk of detention and removal despite following the rules. This creates a perverse incentive: the system encourages people to come forward and regularize their status, but then may punish them for doing so. This kind of legal Catch-22 is what skilled attorneys like Ralph Manginello and our team are adept at navigating, whether in immigration complexities or in challenging insurance company tactics in personal injury cases. Understanding the nuances of regulations and their practical enforcement is key to building a protective strategy.
Consular Processing: The International Legal Dimension
The process of attending an interview at a U.S. consulate abroad (consular processing) is daunting. For some, returning to their home country is dangerous. In such cases, attorneys must explore the extraordinary option of requesting that the interview be held at a U.S. embassy in a third country. This involves intricate international logistics: determining a country the individual can travel to without a visa, and then coordinating with that specific U.S. embassy to see if they will accept the case. This level of complex, multi-jurisdictional problem-solving is akin to the sophisticated coordination required in major personal injury litigation that crosses state lines or involves federal maritime law, areas where our firm’s experience is deep.
Know Your Rights: What To Do If Confronted by Immigration Authorities
This is the most urgent question we hear: “What do I do if ICE stops me?” As attorneys who vigorously defend constitutional rights in criminal cases, we emphasize the following fundamental rights, which apply to everyone in the United States, regardless of immigration status:
- You Have the Right to Remain Silent. You are not required to answer questions about your birthplace, citizenship, or immigration status. You may say, “I choose to remain silent.” If you are not a U.S. citizen, you must provide your name and any immigration documents you have, but you can still remain silent on other questions.
- You Have the Right to Refuse Consent to Search. Do not consent to a search of your person, car, or home. Officers may pat down your clothing if they suspect a weapon, but they need a warrant or probable cause for a more thorough search.
- You Have the Right to Speak to a Lawyer. If you are detained, state clearly, “I want to speak to my lawyer.” You have the right to make a local phone call. The government must provide you with a list of free or low-cost legal services.
- You Have the Right to a Hearing Before an Immigration Judge. Do NOT sign any papers giving up your right to a hearing (like a “Stipulated Removal Order”) without speaking to a lawyer. Signing can waive your chance to fight your case and result in immediate deportation.
- Carry Relevant Documents Safely. If you have a pending case, work permit, or other immigration documents, carry copies (not originals) and your attorney’s contact information.
These rights mirror the protections we assert for every client facing DWI or criminal charges in Houston courts. The principle is the same: the government must follow the law, and you have protections designed to ensure fairness. Our criminal defense practice, backed by Ralph Manginello’s membership in the elite Harris County Criminal Lawyers Association (HCCLA), is built on holding authorities to their burden of proof and protecting these procedural rights.
The Texas Impact: Community, Economy, and Shared Values
The current enforcement strategy has tangible effects on the fabric of Texas. As mentioned, industries from dairy farming in the Panhandle to hotel management in Houston are speaking out about the disruptive impact of losing trained, dedicated workers. This isn’t about advocating for “open borders”—a point of clear agreement in our discussion. It’s about recognizing that a policy of widespread raids on workplaces is economically destructive and sows fear in communities, making people less likely to report crimes, cooperate with police, or seek essential services.
There are alternative approaches that could be more humane, orderly, and economically sensible. As brainstormed in the podcast, a structured self-deportation program or, more effectively, legislative reform to address the root causes of the “trapped” population (like modifying the 10-year bar) would be more in line with American values of practicality and fairness. However, such changes require Congressional action, not just executive orders.
At Attorney911, we see the human cost of legal crises every day. Whether it’s a family torn apart by a wrongful death from an 18-wheeler accident or a parent facing criminal charges, the stress and fear are profound. The current immigration climate creates a similar, pervasive fear in many Texas households. Our role, as always, is to cut through the chaos with knowledge, to advocate for due process, and to provide fierce legal representation when needed.
Why Attorney911’s Legal Expertise Matters in Complex Systems
While The Manginello Law Firm does not practice immigration law, our decades of experience fighting within complex legal and governmental systems provide a relevant framework for understanding these issues. Managing Partner Ralph Manginello, admitted to the Texas Bar in 1998 and to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, has spent over 25 years mastering procedural rules, evidence standards, and the tactics of large, powerful adversaries—whether they are multinational insurance companies or government agencies.
Our firm’s background includes a unique advantage: Associate Attorney Lupe Peña, a third-generation Texan, spent years working at a national defense firm. There, he learned firsthand how large insurance companies investigate claims, value cases, and build strategies to minimize payouts. This insider knowledge is now a powerful weapon for our clients. Similarly, understanding how any government agency operates—its pressures, its protocols, its vulnerabilities—is key to navigating interactions with it. Lupe’s experience is a testament to our core philosophy: to provide the best defense or advocacy, you must understand how the other side thinks and operates.
Our record in high-stakes litigation speaks to our capability. We have secured multi-million dollar settlements for clients with catastrophic injuries, such as a brain injury from a logging accident and a leg amputation following a car crash. We were involved in the historic BP Texas City explosion litigation, taking on a corporate giant. In criminal courts, we’ve achieved dismissals in DWI cases by meticulously challenging breathalyzer maintenance records and missing evidence. Currently, we are litigating a $10 million lawsuit against the University of Houston and a fraternity. We prepare every case as if it’s going to trial because we know that genuine readiness is what forces fair settlements.
This same rigorous, strategic approach is what we advocate for in any legal matter. The system works best when all parties are held to their legal obligations and when individuals are empowered with knowledge of their rights.
Client Trust in Houston and Beyond
Our commitment to communication and results has earned the trust of our community, as seen in our 4.9-star Google rating from over 251 clients. Clients like Jamin Marroquin note, “Mr. Manginello guided me through the whole process with great expertise.” Others, like Donald Wilcox, came to us after another firm rejected his case, and we delivered a successful result. Houston legend Trae Tha Truth has recommended our firm, a point of pride mentioned by clients like Jacqueline Johnson. This trust is built on transparency, tenacity, and treating every client like family—whether they walk into our Houston, Austin, or Beaumont offices or call our emergency line, 1-888-ATTY-911.
Frequently Asked Questions on Immigration and Enforcement
Can ICE agents enter my home without permission?
Generally, no. Immigration officers need a warrant signed by a judge to enter your home without consent. An “administrative warrant” from ICE itself is not enough. You have the right to ask the officer to slide the warrant under the door or hold it up to a window. Verify it has your correct name and address and is signed by a judge. If it does not, you can refuse entry. Do not open the door; speak through it.
What is the “extreme hardship” standard for a waiver?
To qualify for a waiver of the 3 or 10-year bar, you must prove that your qualifying U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse or parent would suffer “extreme hardship” if you were denied admission. This is a higher standard than “normal” hardship but lower than “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship.” Factors include family ties in the U.S., health conditions requiring care, country conditions, and financial impact. Strong documentation from doctors, therapists, economists, and country condition experts is crucial.
Are workplace raids legal?
ICE can conduct investigations and arrests at workplaces, but they must have proper judicial warrants for arrests or, in some cases, may rely on employer consent. The legality of specific raid tactics is often litigated after the fact. The broader concern is the shift in policy priority from targeted arrests of individuals with criminal warrants to large-scale operations at sites chosen for their high likelihood of containing undocumented workers, rather than for specific criminal intelligence.
What should I do if a family member is detained by ICE?
1. Find out where they are being held (the detention facility name and Alien Number, or “A Number”).
2. Contact a reputable immigration attorney or legal services organization immediately.
3. Do not sign any documents sent by ICE for the detained person without an attorney’s review.
4. Begin gathering any documents that prove their ties to the U.S., pending applications, or potential relief.
How does the current climate affect people with pending applications?
It creates significant anxiety. While having a pending application with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) does not grant immunity from enforcement, it is a factor. Individuals with pending asylum claims, U-visa petitions, or family-based petitions should ensure their address is always up-to-date with USCIS and carry proof of their pending case. They remain at risk, especially if they have prior removal orders or criminal history, underscoring the need for expert legal counsel.
Where can I find reliable legal help?
Beware of notarios or consultants who are not attorneys. Seek accredited representatives from non-profit organizations recognized by the Department of Justice or licensed attorneys who specialize in immigration law. The State Bar of Texas and local bar associations can provide referrals. For any related criminal charges or if you are injured and your status is a concern, our firm can provide guidance or appropriate referrals. Call us at 1-888-ATTY-911 for a confidential consultation.
Final Thoughts: Knowledge, Preparation, and Expert Advocacy
The landscape of immigration enforcement in Texas is marked by uncertainty and fear. However, as with any legal emergency, knowledge is your first line of defense. Understanding your fundamental rights, the complexities of the law, and the realities of enforcement can help you make informed decisions and protect your family.
At Attorney911, we believe in the power of skilled legal advocacy to level the playing field. Whether facing an insurance company that refuses to pay a fair settlement after a devastating car accident, criminal charges that threaten your freedom, or simply navigating a complex and intimidating system, having experienced, dedicated attorneys in your corner makes all the difference. Our entire team, from Ralph Manginello and Lupe Peña to our compassionate case managers like Leonor, is committed to fighting for you.
If you or a loved one are facing a legal challenge—whether it’s a personal injury, a criminal matter, or you need guidance on a related issue—do not navigate it alone. Time is always a critical factor in building a strong case. Call the Legal Emergency Lawyers™ at Attorney911 today at 1-888-ATTY-911. We offer free, confidential consultations. We handle cases on a contingency fee basis for personal injury matters, meaning you pay nothing unless we win your case. For criminal defense, we offer flexible payment plans. We serve clients across Texas from our offices in Houston, Austin, and Beaumont, and we have fluent Spanish speakers available. Visit us online at attorney911.com to learn more about our firm, our results, and how we can help you through your legal emergency.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if ICE agents come to my door?
Remain calm. Do not open the door. You have the right to ask if they have a warrant. Speak through the door and ask them to slide a judicial warrant (signed by a judge, not just ICE) under the door or hold it to a window. If they do not have a proper warrant, you can refuse entry. State clearly, “I do not consent to your entry.”
Can I get a work permit if I have a pending immigration case?
It depends entirely on the type of case. Work permits are typically available for specific pending applications, such as asylum, certain family-based petitions (like a U.S. citizen spouse petition), or a U-visa for crime victims. You must file Form I-765 and meet the eligibility criteria for your particular category. An immigration attorney can assess your specific situation.
What is the difference between a 3-year bar and a 10-year bar?
Both are penalties for accruing “unlawful presence” in the U.S. and then leaving. If you were unlawfully present for more than 180 days but less than one year, and then depart, you are barred from returning for 3 years. If you were unlawfully present for one year or more and then depart, you are barred for 10 years. These bars are triggered upon departure, creating a major obstacle for those who need to leave for consular interviews.
What does ‘extreme hardship’ mean for a waiver application?
“Extreme hardship” is the legal standard required to forgive the 3 or 10-year bar. You must prove that your qualifying U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse or parent would suffer hardship that is considerably worse than the normal difficulties expected from family separation. Factors include severe health issues, significant financial loss, lack of access to medical care in the home country, and compelling special needs of U.S. citizen children.
Are ICE raids targeting specific criminals or just anyone?
Despite initial promises to focus on criminals with violent offenses, reports and observations from Texas indicate raids have broadly targeted workplaces like restaurants, hotels, and construction sites, often apprehending individuals with no criminal history. This shift appears driven by quota pressures and targets ‘low-hanging fruit’ rather than conducting intelligence-led operations against specific violent offenders.
Where can I find trustworthy legal help for immigration issues?
Always seek a licensed attorney accredited by the state bar or a Department of Justice-accredited representative from a recognized non-profit organization. Avoid notarios or immigration consultants who are not attorneys. For referrals, contact the State Bar of Texas or local legal aid societies. If your case involves related criminal charges or a personal injury, our firm at Attorney911 can provide guidance and appropriate referrals. Call 1-888-ATTY-911.
